My Rating: ✩✩✩✩✩
I was so excited for a "Down a Dark Hall" vibed book with local lore and spooky academia. What I got was...not quite that.
I enjoyed the local lore. As a transplant to Rhode Island I loved the little hat-tips to local legends and historical sites. Playing "do you think this is Salve or URI?" was a pleasant way to spend time. Bouncing off some TB-Vampire lore, referencing Mercy Brown and the local witch myths was great. I even really like the slight twist on the story to add some new elements for the novel. It was atmospheric, and spooky and had all the hallmarks of a creepy romantasy-meets-horror story that would have been perfect for its fall (ish) release date.
However, the book just never really "took off" for me. The characters were decidedly YA (granted, they are college kids), but in a very "first day on earth" way, not a "coming of age" way. What could have been a very neat melding of historical events and a new element turned tedious because there was so much exposition. Just when you get into the tale, and feel some pieces of the puzzle coming together-it is like four pages of hand holding. The resolution is tidy to the point of triteness after so much over-explained backstory.
So five-stars for premise and spooky factor, one-star for too many other factors.
Published on 11 August 2026 by Dutton
View all my reviews






